Goodreads: Into the Heartless Wood
Published: January 12, 2021
The forest is a dangerous place, where siren song lures men and women to their deaths. For centuries, a witch has harvested souls to feed the heartless tree, using its power to grow her domain.
When Owen Merrick is lured into the witch’s wood, one of her tree-siren daughters, Seren, saves his life instead of ending it. Every night, he climbs over the garden wall to see her, and every night her longing to become human deepens. But a shift in the stars foretells a dangerous curse, and Seren’s quest to become human will lead them into an ancient war raging between the witch and the king who is trying to stop her.
Epic, heartbreaking, and darkly atmospheric, Into the Heartless Wood is the story of impossible love between a monstrous tree siren and a boy who lives at the edge of her wood.
Into the Heartless Wood brings readers to a fantasy world where tree sirens roam– and they are deadly. Against them, men and women try to wield fire and guns, but the forest always regrows. The result is a uniquely imagined and wonderfully atmospheric novel, one that many readers are sure to love, drawn in by the magic and trees and the lyrical prose. However, slow pacing and some minor plot holes lessened my personal excitement for the book.
Roughly the first third of the novel is focused on protagonist Owen setting the scene and then meeting with one of the tree sirens, Seren, who seems different– less inclined to kill, determined perhaps to become something other than the monster she has been. This was interesting to me at first, but I did reach a point where I began to wonder whether anything in particular was going to happen in the novel, or whether I would just be watching Owen and Seren have cutesy forest dates for 300 pages without any sort of rising action, climax, or structure to the book at all.
Things eventually did pick up, and I vacillated between genuinely being excited and wondering what would happen next, and thinking that things were a bit underdeveloped and could use more build-up or explanation. On the plus side, Into the Heartless Wood is a standalone, and I’ll accept a few things being rushed here and there to be able to finish the story in just one book.
Though there is action (just reading the book summary will tell you there’s a war), I’d say the book is truly a romance, and unfortunately that fell flat for me. Owen and Seren both seem like incredibly kind and strong people, but I wasn’t feeling any particularly chemistry between them; I personally didn’t care whether they got together or not, and their flowery thoughts about how much they meant to each other didn’t do anything for me.
The book salvages this, however, by representing some great family dynamics. Owen lost his mother (it’s YA, so of course she’s dead), but he has a vivacious sister who’s two and whom he primarily cares for, and he has his father–who, honestly, is a largely unsung hero of the book. Owen seems vaguely to recognize his father is smart and strong and brave–he’s faced the forest more than once and is always willing to fight for those he loves–but the point is never dwelled on, and I think it’s understated how much the man must have suffered. Seren has more complicated relationships, but watching her navigate her path dealing with her mother and her siblings is fascinating.
While I was expecting more from Into the Heartless Wood after absolutely loving Echo North, it’s a fine book. Readers who want something woodsy and atmospheric and don’t mind a bit of slowness will likely enjoy it. It’s a nice pick if you like fantasy but don’t want over-the-top epic fantasy or drawn-out wars.
Side note: The text in this book is TINY. If miniscule font is not for you, you might enjoy the ebook better.
10 thoughts on “Into the Heartless Wood by Joanna Ruth Meyer”
Great review.. but i’m not sure i’d be able to get into this.
It has such an attractive cover.
I really liked the blurb but I’m not a fan of romance so I’m torn. I do like the sound of the family dynamics though…
The world and concept sounds good. Sad nothing happened much and then things were rushed to rectify that. Great review!
Great review! I actually do think that I will like this one so I am looking forward to picking it up.
I hope you enjoy it!
I’m adding this to my TBR. Sounds like something I might like since it’s set in the woods and is atmospheric. I think I might get annoyed as you did that nothing seems to be happening, but I’m willing to take a chance on it.
I hope you enjoy it! I did think it had its merits. Just sometimes I feel as if authors get caught up in their premise (magical spooky woods!) and forget to work on the other stuff a bit.
While I would actually hate it in practice, sometimes – as an empath – when I read I get REALLY anxious when the main characters are in peril because I REALLY feel what they’re feeling and I think “cutesy forest dates for 300 pages without any sort of rising action, climax, or structure to the book at all” would be the best possible sort of book XD.
That’s actually not a bad point. I remember getting SO STRESSED when I was a kid because I knew bad things were going to happen to the characters in my books, and I didn’t want to see it! A book where they were just going along happily would have been quite nice!
LikeLiked by 1 person
When I watch horror movies (by choice or begrudgingly XD) I often think of that scene in ‘The Office’ where Erin’s talking to the camera and says she likes the first twenty minutes of every horror movie where everyone’s a happy family. Yes! Me, too! Sometimes I think of just stopping the film there and going on to do something else. “Aw, look at that. The Torrences are going to enjoy a lovely winter together at the Overlook Hotel. They have the whole place to themselves! How fun! I bet Jack gets a lot of writing done and they will have so much family fun time. Yay!” It would save me two hours and lots of fear XD.