Mini Reviews (5)

Jack and Jill by Louisa may Alcott

It’s always a bit uncomfortable when you realized a book that was a childhood favorite has imperialistic undertones.  However, if you can get past that, Jack and Jill is in fine Alcott style.  It features a host of boys and girls busy pursuing their dreams, getting up (to us) old-fashioned entertainment, and even beginning to feel the first whispers of love.  I enjoy that, though the title focuses on two characters, their friends receive chapters of their own, making everyone feel chummy and sociable.  (I always thought it odd the March sisters didn’t really seem to have friends, aside from Annie Moffat.)  There’s no real plot here, just a year in the life of characters trying to do better and become better people.  It feels refreshingly wholesome and fans of Little Women will want to check out this story, as well.  (Source: Purchased) Four stars.

The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl: Squirrel Meets World by Shannon Hale and Dean Hale

For about half of the book, I could not get into the story because the authors so clearly think they and protagonist Doreen Green are funny–but I was not laughing.  Doreen just comes across as weird and awkward, and not always in an endearing sort of way.  The worst parts are the end notes, written (strangely) in first person, while the rest of the story is written in third person.  Doreen tries to be funny, but just isn’t.

The book is clearly meant to be fun and silly, so even the not-humorous parts are bizarre, with Squirrel Girl fighting a boy-villain and saving babies with the aid of squirrels.  Weird stuff happens like squirrels being held as ransom and zucchinis masquerading as the victims of villains.  I didn’t mind the weirdness–I assume that’s part of Squirrel Girl’s appeal for most people–but I disliked the forced jokes.  The best parts were the texts between Squirrel Girl and other Marvel heroes–these are actually amusing as they poke fun at the characters.  The rest of the story was not particularly memorable for me, except that I was pleasantly surprised that Doreen’s parents are present and actually care about her–a rarity in children’s literature.  The first in a series.  (Source: Library) Three Stars.

Right Ho, Jeeves by P. G. Wodehouse

I went into this volume believing it was another anthology of short stories featuring the intelligent Jeeves rescuing his employer’s friends from various awkward situations.  In fact, this is a novel dedicated to a series of difficulties: Bertie’s aunt needs money, his cousin broke off her engagement, and his friend is too shy to speak to the girl he loves.  Bertie is convinced he, and not Jeeves, will solve these crises and so ensues a series of mishaps only Bertie can create.  Readers will find themselves greatly entertained by the convoluted schemes and the mishaps they create.  This is Bertie and Jeeves in fine style.  If you’re looking for a light, comical story, look no farther.  (Source: Library) Four Stars.

Searching for Dragons by Patricia C. Wrede

I enjoyed the humor of the first book in the series, Dealing with Dragons, and the ways in which Wrede plays with fairy tale tropes.  Unfortunately, the sequel lacks the magic of the first book.  King Mendenbar comes across as whiny, Cimorene as rude, and the magician Telemain as annoying.  This is odd as I think they are supposed to come across as delightfully unconventional, spunky, and funny, respectively.  The plot is dull and consists mainly of Mendenbar and Cimorene never getting where they want to go and running into random characters who are meant to be amusing but failed to amuse me.  I miss the charm and wit of the first book.  (Source: Library) Three Stars.

Krysta 64

11 thoughts on “Mini Reviews (5)

  1. Michael J. Miller says:

    This makes me sad to hear the Squirrel Girl novel didn’t work very well! I adore her comics by Ryan North and Erica Henderson and I think she’s one of the best characters Marvel has out right now. It’s a shame to hear it didn’t all translate as well into the YA novel format.


    • Krysta says:

      I’m kind of interested in how the comics work and whether the novelization is similar or not. Unfortunately, I don’t think my library currently has Squirrel Girl, so I might eventually have to look into an ILL.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Michael J. Miller says:

        My 100th post was a tribute to Squirrel Girl because I love what they’re doing on the title so much (it was “The Subversive Genius of Squirrel Girl” and yes, I feel pretentious citing myself but I’m trying to underscore how much I love it). Ryan North (the author) has a very unique written voice and his sense of comedic timing is just as unique. As I was reading your short review, I was wondering if it felt awkward because the authors were trying to pull of something so specific yet wasn’t organic for them. I don’t know. If/when you check the title out, I’d be excited to hear your thoughts!


        • Krysta says:

          At least knowing the author is useful. Sometimes comics are intimidating because I have no clue where I’m supposed to start. (Usually it’s with whatever is on the shelf at the library, but it is still useful to know if this is a new Batgirl or what is happening!)

          Liked by 1 person

          • Michael J. Miller says:

            When I came back to reading comics after my seventeen years off, I felt much the same way. As a kid I’d naturally just jump in and read whatever I wanted but it was oddly intimidating going back in as an adult. Not knowing where I am in a story is more disorienting as an adult than it ever was as a kid, at least for me.


            • Krysta says:

              That’s a good point. I see kids at the library who will take any book in a series. And I get confused because I usually would have to read them in order, even if I had already read the series. They don’t seem to mind, though! It must be a really freeing way to read. I wouldn’t know. 😉

              Liked by 1 person

    • Krysta says:

      Jack and Jill used to be one of my favorite Alcott books. Then my library weeded it. 😦 It’s possibly on Project Gutenberg or otherwise available as I imagine the copyright has run out.


Leave a Reply! We'd love to read your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.