Goodreads: Romeo and Juliet
The feud between the Capulets and the Montagues is a plague upon the city of Verona, where swordfights between the factions constantly break out in the streets. How unfortunate then that Juliet Capulet should fall in love with Romeo Montague! Gareth Hinds adapts Shakespeare’s famous play into a graphic novel.
Plenty of graphic novel versions of Shakespeare exists for the teen trying to get through high school or just ace the standardized test. Many are geared specifically for these types of educational purposes, meaning that the artwork is often secondary to the desire for the creators to offer a legible text, whether that means putting Shakespeare’s words into modern English or otherwise adapting it for simplicity. Gareth Hinds’ work, while dedicated to teachers, goes beyond mere utilitarian purposes; it is a work of art, not a study cheat sheet.
The artwork alone stands out. Here you get glorious color, not cheap black-and-white, as well as a nice amount of detail. The illustrations are layed out thoughtfully to create meaning in the text. And the depictions of the characters show real emotion, real action. You can tell there’s thought behind each scene, a real desire to convey the story and to elicit a response in the reader. The art is not secondary here; it’s a part of the work.
The thoughtfulness of the illustrations actually makes it easier to follow the text even though Hinds doesn’t modernize it like a “No Fear” adaptation (though he does abridge the work). It mirrors the action one might see on stage, so one can understand that a person is lying or a person is upset or a person is about to draw his sword. If you can’t follow the words, you can follow the art.
The words themselves are layed out thoughtfully. Often graphic novels like these seem to put all the major speeches in one large block of text on a page. This does not really work well in the graphic novel medium. Hinds finds a way to break up the text and still make it clear that it’s all of a part. He doesn’t lose the power of a speech by trying too hard to highlight that power.
All of this is interestingly part of a work that seems to want to present itself as somewhat scholarly. It comes with a dramatis personae, with footnotes, with a note about the texts consulted. It also explains the decision to present a multiracial story–not, Hinds says, to comment on race divisions but instead to highlight the “universality” of the play. The implication is that this is a work to be taken seriously, even if graphic novels generally are not.
Altogether, reading this adaptation was a treat. The artwork really makes the story come alive, suggesting the emotions and staging one might see in a theatre performance. Those who find reading Shakespeare dull because they have difficult imagining the staging themselves might see the Bard anew through the eyes of Hinds.
13 thoughts on “Romeo and Juliet by Gareth Hinds (A Graphic Novel Adaptation)”
I’ll have to look into this one!! Great resource. 😊
It really is!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ohhhh this sounds so interesting. And I’ve been getting into graphic novels a lot more lately, so I’ll have to check it out!
It’s admittedly difficult to find a good Shakespeare adaptation. This one works very well, however!
I love Shakespeare, and I’ve never seen a graphic novel of one of his plays before. I’ll have to check this out.
I’ve read quite a few R&J adaptations. Most aren’t particularly inspiring, sadly.
Ah I love the sound of this- especially since you said the artwork is done so well!! And it’s really great that it’s done in a way that’s more scholarly, so that it’s designed to be taken seriously- that’s interesting for a graphic novel. Great review!
I feel sorry for graphic novels, actually, that this one would have to mimic the set-up of a version of play in order for people to take it seriously. I’ve noticed, though, that high school educators tend to view these types of adaptations as literacy tools rather than works of art in their own right, so it’s not surprising Hinds would appeal to that market by positioning his text as something that would lead the readers to Shakespeare, the “real” work of art.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah yes, that’s true- I wish more attention was given to graphic novels, cos I’m only just getting into them now and feel like I missed out on a lot because I was never recommended them before.
Me, too! I’ve really only started reading them in the past year or so and I have so much to catch up on!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes me too!!
This looks like a beautiful book! I’m glad you enjoyed it 🙂
It is very pretty! I hope they release more titles!