Emily of New Moon by L. M. Montgomery (Review 2)


Goodreads: Emily of New Moon
Series: Emily #1
Source: Purchased
Published: 1923


With her father dead, Emily Byrd Starr has been taken in by her mother’s people, Aunts Elizabeth and Laura, and Cousin Jimmy, whom she’s never met before.  Aunt Elizabeth, however, seems very harsh.  But as the days go by, Emily learns to love her home at New Moon and to make friends from the artistic Teddy Kent to the wild Ilse Burnley.  And all the while she’s perfecting her craft of poetry as she prepares to be a writer.


Anne Shirley may be L. M. Montgomery’s most famous heroine, but Emily of New Moon possesses her own unique charms.  Sensitive to beauty, possessed of a strong sense of justice, and endowed with the famed Murray pride, Emily bears some similarities to Anne but is ultimately her own character.  Her adventures are not the misadventures of Anne but  the typical ones of childhood–attempting to fit in at school, being subjected to the teacher’s sarcasm, visiting relatives, and having her first real fight with a friend.  Montgomery transforms it all, making Emily’s pain and delight come to life in equal measure.

Of course, Montgomery also exhibits here her signature characterization, introducing the harsh and proud Aunt Elizabeth, the softer Aunt Laura, and the elfin Cousin Jimmy to round out Emily’s new home.  The other characters are also described richly, until one feels that these individuals could be met in real life.  Emily’s cruel, sarcastic teacher; the fiery Ilse Burnley and her neglectful father; the sharp-tongued Aunt Nancy, and more are drawn in detail and not spared from Montgomery’s keen eye (or Emily’s, when she writes about them).

Here also is Montgomery’s love of beauty and of nature.  Emily has her enchanted haunts to roam, her imaginary friends to play with.  She can envision trees as Adam and Eve, know the Wind Woman by name, and risk her life for a bouquet of flowers.  And yet neither the book nor Emily ever feel sentimental.  One simply accepts that life is indeed beautiful–and it’s impossible not to feel a bit privileged to be one of Montgomery’s readers, to have her share her vision with you.

Perhaps most interestingly is Emily’s aspiration to become a writer.  Many of her experiences feel autobiographical, from her burning need to write despite opposition to her sorrow over finding her old stories aren’t so good after all.  Her highs and lows prove absorbing material, and I can’t wait to follow her story through the next two books.

As always, Montgomery delivers a charming and magical story, yet one still grounded in the everyday realities of life and in the quirks and foibles of ordinary people.  Her ability to make the ordinary so enchanted is a rare gift indeed.

5 StarsKrysta 64

6 thoughts on “Emily of New Moon by L. M. Montgomery (Review 2)

  1. Briana says:

    think the Emily series is also where Montgomery’s interest in the supernatural comes about. I love Emily, but Montgomery does represent her as a bit uncanny, albeit in a “mysterious, captivating” way.


    • Krysta says:

      Montgomery was extremely prolific. She also wrote Pat of Silver Bush and Mistress Pat, Magic for Marigold, Jane of Lantern Hill, The Story Girl and The Golden Road, Kilmeny of the Orchard, A Tangled Web, The Blue Castle, and tons of short stories (some of which have been collected and published). 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      • TeacherofYA says:

        Holy cow!! I had no idea. I’m surprised you’re giving them a read bc of their age, but I think they might speak to a new audience of girls…so I’m reading every review to see what I could use for my kids in the future!


        • Krysta says:

          I think Anne and Montgomery have been wildly popular since Anne’s first publication. They’ve aged really well and I doubt Anne has ever been out of print. Prince Edward Island, in fact, seems to embrace Anne for tourism purposes, so clearly she’s selling. And they just did another Anne movie (though I hear it’s kind of different from the book) that’s been getting a lot of hype. So it’s a pretty great time to be a Montgomery fan. Lots of stuff is happening!


Leave a Reply! We'd love to read your thoughts!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.