Here is the fourth set of discussion questions for our Anne of Green Gables read-along. If you would like to sign up, you are free to do so at any point throughout the read-along. The sign-up post also has the schedule for the event, including discussion questions and other activities.
Feel free to answer the questions on your own blog and leave us a link in the comments, or just answer in the comments. You can also answer the questions even if you are not officially reading with us.
The final recap and review will be posted next Sunday. To tweet about the read-along, you can use the hashtag #readAnneShirley.
From The Annotated Anne of Green Gables edited by Wendy E. Barry, Margart Anne Doody, and Mary E. Doody Jones.
With the Normal School qualification combined with high school completion, a girl could teach at age sixteen. A boy was supposed to be eighteen, although exceptions did occur. Because Gilbrt is two years older than Anne, they are able to become teachers at the same time…Men and women in Anne’s day were on a different pay scale for the same work. Gilbert could therefore better afford to pay board than Anne…Women thus became attractive to employers as they would take less pay. (431)
- What do you think of Anne’s competitive spirit studying for and then getting into Queen’s? Were you expecting her to do so well academically?
- How did you feel about Matthew’s death? Do you think this was foreshadowed?
- Did you get the resolution between Anne and Gilbert that you were hoping for?
- What do you think about the plan to sell Green Gables?
- Overall, how did you like the book?
- Do you have any plans to read the rest of the stories or more books by Montgomery after this?
- I think this is one of those tricky areas in books where part of me wants the character to get everything. Of course I want Anne to be first on the pass list. Of course I want her to win all the awards. But part of me also thinks this might be a little too convenient or cliche. Does every character have to be the “most” special? I think Montgomery did some nice tempering here. Anne is very good, but she’s not necessarily a genius, and she does have some serious competition.
- I was about ten when I first read the book, but I think I was rather taken by surprise, even with the vague hints about Matthew’s heart and the banks. If I’d thought more about it, I probably wouldn’t have expected a beloved major character to die off in the first book of a series. However, being ten, I didn’t know anything about the publication history of the novel. Montgomery thought it would be a stand-alone and said herself she wouldn’t have killed him that early if she’d known there would be more books.
- I always want a little more Gilbert than there is. 😉 However, I think the resolution really fits Montgomery’s style, and I love that we get to see what a kind person Gilbert is, even to people who aren’t necessarily kind to him.
- After Matthew died, I think I could have believed Montgomery would do anything in this novel. Say good-bye to Green Gables, everyone! Obviously I think the idea is heart-breaking, but it’s completely understandable decision on Marilla’s end.
- It’s still one of my favorite books. I’m stunned each time I reread it by just how it is, and how it continue to live up to my expectations.
- I’ve read the rest of the series previously, so I’m not going to embark on it right now. I have been reading some of Montgomery’s other books this summer, like Kilmeny of the Orchard and Emily of New Moon.