Guest Review: The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien

Tolkien 2012

Since the theme of this year’s Tolkien Reading Day is “75 Years of The Hobbit,” we begin our event with a review of that work.

Andrea is the blogger from The Overstuffed Bookcase, a book blog of mostly young adult book reviews, with occasional adult book reviews thrown into the mix.  She is a wife, mother, Harry Potter fanatic and Dr. Pepper addict.  You can read more of her reviews at

I may be one of the few readers out there who hasn’t actually read many of J.R.R. Tolkien’s works.  I read The Hobbit as a teen and, even though I own all three The Lord of the Rings books, The Hobbit remains, to this day, the only Tolkien I have had the pleasure of reading.  Never fear, Tolkien fans, I plan to rectify this soon!

Even though my Tolkien expertise is nonexistent, I was thrilled when Briana and Krysta asked me to be a part of their Tolkien Reading Event, and I jumped at the chance to re-read The Hobbit and write a review.  So bear with me – this is my first time reading The Hobbit with a critical eye, and I’m sure all of my thoughts have been said before by many Tolkien scholars who are much more eloquent.

First of all, Tolkien’s writing is so superb that it is no wonder that his stories have become classics.  The Hobbit is considered by many (and perhaps was by Tolkien himself) to be a book for children, and Tolkien was obviously in agreement with many of the authors of children’s and young adult books of today who believe that they should not “dumb down” their writing simply because it is aimed at a younger audience.  But, as with so many authors today, his writing can be (and should be, in my opinion) read and enjoyed by people of all ages.

Tolkien’s characters and world-building are basically flawless, and with the help of a few maps and pictures, readers become the fifteenth member of the troupe of heroes as they set their backs upon Bilbo’s home in The Hill.  We are there with Bilbo, Gandalf, and the dwarves as they narrowly escape the goblins of the Misty Mountains; we, too, find ourselves lost once the party steps off the path into Mirkwood; and we rack our brains trying to come up with a plan to escape the dungeons of the wood elves, or to outwit the dragon Smaug.

The only drawback I found, and it is a small one, is that several of the dwarves in Bilbo’s party were not thoroughly fleshed out.  We got a good sense of Thorin, Bombur, Fili, Kili, and a few others, but many of them seemed to simply be there so that with Bilbo they were fourteen in number, and also to create a humorous scene in the beginning when they all show up on Bilbo’s doorstep.  However, I really did enjoy the humor.  It reminds me of how Douglas Adams would fabricate a situation and then explain how that caused something in our actual history.  For example, Tolkien had Bilbo say, “Escaping goblins to be caught by wolves,” and then Tolkien added, “and it became a proverb, though now we say ‘out of the frying-pan into the fire’ in the same sort of uncomfortable situations.”  As a lover of British comedy, I enjoyed all the subtle hints of humor that Tolkien sprinkled throughout this tale.

I also enjoyed the dichotomy between Bilbo and Gandalf at the beginning.  The hobbits who are most respected are those who are rich, and don’t get into any “adventures.”  When Gandalf first comes upon Bilbo, Bilbo uses polite phrases such as “Good morning” and “I beg your pardon,” and Gandalf points out that these phrases have more meanings than most of us realize.  Here, I believe Tolkien is commenting on how society regards politeness, and Gandalf represents a person whom some people would consider “uncivilized,” simply because he does not behave like the rest of them.  Perhaps there is even more here, and Tolkien is showing the diversity of society between those who are privileged and those who aren’t, and how they each behave and believe the world should be.  Or perhaps Tolkien is simply suggesting that a life not lived to its fullest is not a life lived at all.

The Hobbit is full of complex characters, interesting creatures, and such suspense that even readers who visit the tale for a second or third time may find themselves anxious for Bilbo and his companions.  It is easy to see why The Hobbit continues to be loved by people of all ages, and why J.R.R. Tolkien’s works have become the very definition of epic fantasy.  I would highly recommend this book to lovers of fantasy, yet I would also recommend this to anyone who simply loves a good book.

6 thoughts on “Guest Review: The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien

  1. midnightbookgirl says:

    Great review, Andrea! It’s been a looooong time since I’ve read the Hobbit, but you’ve made me want to re-read it. I did read the Lord of the Rings trilogy when the movies were out, but I didn’t enjoy them half as much as I did The Hobbit. I’m excited for The Hobbit movie, so I’m definitely going to have to read the book again as soon as possible. Thanks for reminding me that even though the LoTR books weren’t my all time favorites, The Hobbit was.


  2. David says:

    Prodded by the looming release of The Hobbit movie, I’ve decided that this is the year I must reread the book and The Lord of the Rings. They’ve been at the top of my literary pantheon for ages now, but I haven’t read any of them since my freshman year of high school. More of my time has been spent in The Silmarillion and the following tomes of unfinished and lost tales, all of which are fascinating and, importantly, shorter than the great novels.

    I appreciate reading your review, Andrea, as it represents a relatively fresh look at an old classic. With the “good morning” scene, it always said to me that Gandalf (and thus Tolkien) was pointing out how much depth the world around us has that we aren’t even aware of — particularly the language we use. Tolkien being a philologist, of course — a great student of languages and their development — he would naturally be aware of the great depths of our linguistic heritage and want to promote it!


  3. Courtney says:

    Great review Andrea! I also can’t wait for my chance to go back and reread the Hobbit and the LoTR. I actually remember liking LoTR more then the Hobbit but I might have been rushing through it. It is hard to remember seeing on how it was soooooooo long ago! But I do remember when all the dwarfs first showed up at Bilbo’s door and imposed on him. I always felt bad for Bilbo because he was trying so hard!


Leave a Reply! We'd love to read your thoughts!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.